We offer some of the biggest, juiciest burgers you’ll ever put in your mouth as well as the tastiest cheese steaks south of Philly. Come taste what Benchwarmers Tavern & Grill in Mount Sinai is doing to transform classic American cuisine.Ample parking is located near Benchwarmers Tavern & Grill. Neighborhood Tavern and Grill with a delicious, hearty homestyle menu. 6,906 were here. Mount Sinai School District » Parents » Food Services Click here to access all menus. Savino's Hideaway | 258 North Country Road Mount Sinai, NY 11766 | (631) 928-6510 | Map Closed Mondays Tuesday through Thursday: Lunch 11:30am - 3:00pm • Dinner 3:00pm - 10:00pm “Benchwarmer Sampler” $13.95: Crunchy hard shell tacos served with a side of salsa, sour cream and melted american cheese (4) Wings, (4) Mozzarella sticks, (4) Mini Tacos, and (4) Potato Skins “Pretzel Sticks” $9.95 “Smothered Nachos" $14.95 View the menu for Benchwarmer's and restaurants in Mount Sinai, NY. Benchwarmers is a nice restaurant/bar in mt Sinai. Specialties: Great service, great food, Happy Hour 3pm-8pm, includes dining area, secluded and quite dining area, friendly staff, Restaurant menu, map for Bench Warmer's Tavern & Grill located in 11766, Mount Sinai NY, 23 Route 25A. Open for lunch and dinner, Benchwarmer’s Grill serves crowd-pleasing favorites – our customers often tell us just how much they love our food. 6,904 were here. See restaurant menus, reviews, hours, photos, maps and directions. Neighborhood Tavern and Grill with a delicious, hearty homestyle menu. Overall a fantastic experience that nobody should miss. 6,570 were here. This is a great establishment with amazing food and a fun atmosphere. Different events posted throughout the week (don't miss prime rib night). FOR SAFETY ONLY ON-LINE PAYMENTS USING "MySchoolBucks" WILL BE ACCEPTED TO PURCHASE BREAKFAST/LUNCH - Neighborhood Tavern and Grill with a delicious, hearty homestyle menu. 6,900 were here. Neighborhood Tavern and Grill with a delicious, hearty homestyle menu. Store your bike at a nearby rack and enjoy a bite to eat at Benchwarmers Tavern & Grill.There's no need to bust your budget at Benchwarmers Tavern & Grill, with most meals costing under $15.